About Us

Eastern Mutual is dedicated to providing top quality insurance programs that meet the financial needs of our policyholders and to delivering those programs via independent agents in a manner that exceeds our policyholders’ expectations.

Eastern Mutual is committed to delivering our products through a network of local, independent agencies. In a business dominated by technology, we believe the personal touch is important. We believe that a local insurance professional is best qualified to assist you in establishing a quality insurance program that is cost …


The Eastern Mutual Insurance Company has grown from a local fire insurance association, founded in 1855, to a mutual insurance company serving the eastern and central regions of upstate New York. The original association was founded on the concept of neighbors helping neighbors in a time of crisis. Although our “neighborhood” has grown over the past 160+ years, Eastern Mutual still strives to provide neighborly assistance in times of need.

Commercial Insurance Buildings Icon

Commercial Insurance

Personal Insurance House Icon

Personal Insurance

Farmowners Insurance Barn Icon

Farmowners Insurance